Women Who Earn More Than Men: A Girl's Guide to Being the Bigger Breadwinner
Alamy.comIt wasn't until the couple moved in together that Bowman found out she was making substantially more money than he was. What started as a few thousand dollars in income disparity then has now turned into her making quadruple what he earns through his business of owning a bike shop.
It was a period when her husband was unemployed for more than a year that really shaped their financial relationship. "During that time I became the chief financial officer of the household," says Bowman, who is a writer and author of "Project: Happily Ever After." While it wasn't a title she wanted to take on, "It's definitely not one he wants, either."
And Bowman's not alone.
Now more than ever, studies show women are the breadwinners in their marriages and romantic relationships. According to Pew Research, between 1970 and 2007, the number of men whose wives out-earn them increased from 4 percent to 22 percent. And, as we all know, the subject of money -- who handles it and, especially, who makes more of it -- can be a minefield for a couple.
While some women (and men) are totally comfortable with dual, non-matching incomes, there's also proof in the celebrity world that men are more likely to cheat on women who make more than they do (Jesse James and Sandra Bullock's messy situation could be a prime example).
When Beverly Hills licensed marriage and family therapist Alisa Ruby Bash sees couples in her office presenting this discrepancy as a problem in their relationship, it runs the gamut. "Is this an extreme case of one person working and one person sitting at home watching TV?" she says, "Or are both people on their career paths, and the discrepancy between their two salaries is minimal?"
Pewsocialtrends.orgAccept That Financial Opposites Attract
Part of the reason why your money-savvy self may love a guy who throws financial caution to the wind could be science, says money management expert Manisha Thakor, founder of the Women's Financial Literacy Initiative.
"Often, savers and spenders become attracted to each other," she says. "Academics have surmised it's because there is something financially intoxicating about 'financial otherness' that draws couples to each other to begin with." But after the initial attraction to that novelty wears off, financial tensions start to build. Thakor says that much of the tension she sees in couples where the female makes more has to do with this saver/spender dichotomy as opposed to who is the bigger breadwinner.
In Bowman's case, her husband follows the budget she determines with little say or interest in money management. "This, I feel, gives me too much power in some respects," Bowman says. "It forces me into an authoritarian role that I'm not particularly comfortable in. It also stresses me out because it's my salary that pays the essential bills most of the time." Bowman worries about the mortgage and other major payments; her husband doesn't.
Consider His Upbringing
While dollars and cents are certainly an important aspect of any relationship, Alisa Ruby Bash says that, in her estimation, certain types of men are more comfortable being with females who make more than they do. A few of these types include men who are more creative, paid sporadically, starting a new business, or have grown up with a strong female role model which could include being raised by a single mother or a mother who was the breadwinner.
The other end of the spectrum would include men who were spoiled and raised to feel entitled or, in certain extreme cases, "trophy men," who enjoy being taken care of at your expense. In Bash's findings, men less likely to be accepting of a woman's dominant financial role tend to be more traditional or have been raised in more traditional cultures.
An accountant at a private equity firm in New York City, Melissa says her man's laid-back, go-with-the-flow personality is a boon to dealing with this situation in their own relationship. However, there is some stress for her when it comes to figuring out who will pay for what travel expenses, which fuels the couple's long-distance relationship. "I make more money, and flights between our two cities can get kind of expensive," she says, "but he has a more flexible travel schedule. I've offered to split travel costs, but so far he's taken care of it himself. He also makes a point of paying for everything when we are together."
Not surprisingly, women who were accustomed to a different role model growing up tend to have a more difficult time accepting this financial scenario. "We internalize expectations and ideas we have for our partners," says Bash. "If a woman with a successful, hardworking father falls for a less ambitious guy who is not sure what he wants to do with his life, eventually something will feel wrong, no matter how much she loves him. Often, this point of contention, which can be so deep or even subconscious, will haunt the couple throughout their relationship."
Examine Your Attitude Toward Money
Ultimately, it all comes down to attitude. "If the woman feels resentful or judgmental, it will eventually come out," says Bash. If this is a hot topic for you, discuss finances during the beginning months of your relationship.
Many women have high expectations, especially when it comes to men and money. A go-getter who falls for a guy who's not quite as go-getting can cause a lot of frustration and resentment. In order to bridge the financial gap, Thakor has increasingly seen female breadwinners sitting down with their partners as equals, "dividing financial tasks based on each person's interests, time availability, and skill levels." If the woman is the breadwinner, maybe her man will take care of family responsibilities and social activities, grocery shopping, making meals, paying bills and taking on other household chores. Whatever the breakdown of responsibility, both parties have to feel that they have an equal share for the relationship to flourish.
Over the course of her marriage, Bowman has felt a "combination of powerful and stressed out. I like that I'm successful, but there are times that I fantasize about taking a year off from work." As Thakor suggests, Bowman includes her husband in as many decisions as possible, giving him domains where he's in charge. "He needed to be the boss somewhere in the house, so he's the boss of the laundry."
Bottom line, says Thakor, "When it comes to financial tension in a household, increasingly I'm seeing it driven more by each person's emotional relationship to money as opposed to gender."
Decide How to Divide and Conquer
As the saying goes, time is money. And when the woman in the household is the primary breadwinner, this can be the biggest issue a salary disparity creates.
You'll need to decide together how to tackle tasks in a way that satisfies you both, explains Thakor, making sure domestic tasks are fairly divided and, when appropriate, outsourcing or paring back. If you work an 80-hour week while your partner works a more standard 40 hours or not at all, a 50/50 split of household tasks may not leave enough hours in the day for you to maintain a functioning household, let alone your sanity. "The notion of what is a fair and equitable distribution of non-financial tasks really comes into play here," she emphasizes.
Factor in the Job Market
Many of us -- men in particular -- have experienced being laid off in the course of this recession. If a woman is still working while her partner is not, she may start to feel resentful, say the experts, especially if she feels he's not trying hard enough to look for new work.
"She's working, juggling kids and household chores, and if her partner isn't stepping up to either relieve some of the household burden or find a new source of income," says Thakor, "that's when I'm seeing the financial firecrackers."
Bear in mind: It's the effort and attitude of both parties, more than the actual dollar amounts, that Thakor sees as what causes the most friction in couples. But if you can carve out roles within a relationship that you're both comfortable with, that can help pave over subtle differences in salary.
"I sometimes find myself feeling envious of women who are married to husbands who earn more, have a job with health insurance, or have a steady income," confesses Bowman. "That said, I've gotten used to our roles over the years, and I think I might have a hard time adjusting to a different role if it came down to it. I've grown into CFO of the family. It wasn't easy, but now I'm used to it and it would be a huge adjustment to get used to a different financial relationship."
Vanessa Voltolina is an editor and freelance writer living in New York City. She covers health, nutrition, fitness and relationships. Find her on Twitter (@vvoltolina) and read more of her stories at her website. Check out more video from MyDaily!
Around the Web
- What Drives Men Away and What Attracts Them - YourTango
- Bill Clinton: It's Still the Economy, Stupid - The Daily Beast
- Do You Want to Know When Your Friends Run Into Your Ex? - The Frisky
- Would You Marry Someone Who Didn't Have a Job? - The Gloss
- And the City That Has the Most Sex Is ... - The Stir, CafeMom
- 3 Easy Ways to Keep Your Makeup Sweat-Proof This Summer - BellaSugar
Add a Comment
First, let me say that I just finished Alissa's book and it is fantastic. Her marriage/earning situation is completely different from mine and so my comment does not apply to her...
Now having said that, it's key to remember that successful marriages can go on for many, many years and that income situations can change a great deal over time. There have been times when I have been out-earning my husband by quite a bit and there have been times when his income has completely outpaced mine.
The key is to think of yourselves as contributors to overall household. In fact, I often refer to our family of 4 as "Team Mihm." It may sound corny, but the mindset really works -- everyone pitches in all sort of ways, whether financially or not.
This seemed bound to happen... Society told the girls and young women of Generation X that they could be anything, do anything and achieve anything (Girl Power, right?)...while the boys' needs from public education and from society were cast aside and even subtracted, leaving them to be lost and forgotten and even robbed of their masculinity. I suppose society figured that males "had our turn". I wonder how many boys in the '80s were put on Ritalin because they acted like boys...but I digress. Good or bad, Title IX comes along and a generation of boys and men already confused and seeking their identity sees even more opportunity taken away. I am all about equality, and Title IX is just a single example, but the disparity of treatment between girls and young women and of the boys and young men by our public education system and by society at large would certainly have long-term consequences down the road. Just read the above article. Comparatively little emphasis was placed on the success of boys and young men...it was years of "YOU GO GIRL!" You remember...I do, too. Is it to anyone's surprise that boys were being outperformed from college down to the elementary school level? Emphasis on male success was nil. Somewhere between "I am Woman, Hear Me Roar" and "Girl Power", society failed our boys.
Some men of my generation were able to hold on to what was left of our collective masculinity and pursue jobs in transportation, manufacturing and construction. Everyone calls the current "Great Recession" (cough...cough...it's a DEPRESSION, people! cough) the "MAN-cession". A greedy corporate America outsourcing jobs and laying off workers to appease shareholders while they rake in unprecedented profits has sucked what little testosterone was left in our bodies, currently weakened from the absence of intercollegiate athletics or any emphasis on boyhood, into oblivion. Industries traditionally dominated by men seemed to have been hit the hardest.
I hate this phrase...my boss used it when I was let go from my management job in the transportation industry...but "it is what it is". I do not know what the results of this will be...surely there will be both positives and negatives. However, I do not doubt that we are still failing our boys and because of that something stands to be lost. I am not sure what the ultimate result of society's decision to de-value the collective testosterone of Generation X will be, but there will have to be implications in the future, right? Implications that modern woman will have to live with...
So yes...woman...I hear you roar... Just try to keep the roaring to a minimum, mmmkay...I'm trying to watch Oprah and Cupcake Wars.
Oh, honestly. Stop playing the gender binary card. The only reason such a concept exists is because ignorant people won't let go of it.
March 02 2011 at 8:12 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyShow me these women. I'd like to meet them :) Hats off to them and their success
March 02 2011 at 7:24 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replyi was the bread winner for 25 yrs as a self employed plumber. massive heary attack 7 yrs ago. i still work 49 hrs and make good money. now women are gaining in heart problems. burn your bra baby but is it worth it?
March 02 2011 at 6:55 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyLike I should have a problem like this?
I don't think so.
I would absolutely have no problem whatsoever if my wife made more than I do.
Anyone who does may just another problem and that is being secure in his manhood.
Again, just my 2c
these women a far from "breadwinners" (which always referred to a single partner who made the money for the family).
"breadwinners" have accepted this as one's SOLE responsibility.
the stress and pressure involved is infinitiely more severe than a person who shares the monetary contribution to the family.
i know because my wife (a medical doctor) has assumed this heavy duty for our family for some 30 years while i've been lucky enough to raises our five children.
classifying women who just happen to make more than their spouse as "breadwinners" is an insult to all the REAL "breadwinners" out there.
Bravo, Bill. Kudos to you for having that insight; and for making your situation work for 30 years.
March 02 2011 at 6:24 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI think this article got it wrong, atleast in some aspects. They make it out to be like, if the man makes less $ then he's not ambitious or sits at home, or has more free time. Sometimes, not making as much as the wife just works out that way, not b/c any of the former reasons.
For instance, I, the female, make more $, but my hubby works just as many hours (if not more) and probably way harder. However, I busted my butt through college to get a higher paying job, not that it pays very high, just more than his. He hasn't had the opportunity to continue his education yet and he is a felon - which really makes it hard to get a decent paying job. Though he is very ambitious, pitches in on housework and evenly splits the main bills. He does all he can with what he has and is none of how the writer paints the picture of these kinds of men. I pay for the extras like pet care and travel, but why wouldn't I when I can? Its so not a big deal. Why should he stress over it when the $ is there, why not just enjoy yourselves, each other and marriage instead of fighting over who pays for what? The only time that should happen is if the guy really is just lazy and unwilling to do what is necessary to atleast be able to pitch in where he should be.
Wow... I love it. I think a woman should be paid the same as a man doing the same job. Now no more long faces, bad attitudes, manipulation, withholding sex, and "you make more money than me" excuses. For not taking men on vacations, paying her own traffic tickets, buying men gifts, clothes, dinners, lunches, overnight getaways, car payments, rent, gas, car repairs, mortgage, engagement rings, and drinks. No more free "ladies night" free drink nights "ladies get in free nights." She can pay her own electric bills, cell phone bills, cable bills, and out-of-town shopping spree bills. She no longer has to hide money, credit card statements, price tags on extra shoes and clothes hidden in the back of her closet. I no longer have to save every cent for household items, weddings, and wedding accessories she wants. She now can help pay for the honeymoon, buy herself flowers, take her friends out with her money, pay for her own spas, pedicures, manicures, and hair and hair products. Child support payments can now be more reasonable for men, and equally distributed, no more 100 million dollar payouts because you met her and she decided to miraculously get pregnant while telling you she's on birth control, no more ridiculous alimony and palimony payment because she's a female. And finally, do away with the pathetic excuse "that men are supposed to treat the lady on the first date."
March 02 2011 at 4:36 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyThe woman's movement wanted women to be treated as equals. Worrying about paying bills, the financial future and having to bird-dog someone else' spending comes with the package.
It's time to put your big-girl pants on and join the fight.
I second that motion! Who ever you are you made me laugh...so right.
March 02 2011 at 7:10 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
23 Comments